Article

A Promise Should Create Work for the Person Making It

October 31, 2026

A girl asked to give up school has to live with a decision that other people may find quite easy to explain. There will be reasons, perhaps presented as necessities. Yet the person whose future is being narrowed may have the least say in the matter.

That is worth remembering when we encounter a large, encouraging number. DW reports 1.2 million pledges to keep girls in school, alongside efforts to secure justice for Maya women, in a story about people recognised by the UN. The pledges are significant as expressions of intention. The headline alone cannot tell us how many will become lasting changes in someone’s life.

There is a temptation to be cynical about promises. It costs very little to agree that girls should receive an education or that women should have access to justice. But dismissing a public commitment too quickly lets the person making it off rather easily. A promise gives us something to return to. You said this mattered. What have you done since?

The difficulty comes when keeping that promise starts to interfere with ordinary arrangements. A commitment may require money, time, an awkward conversation, or a challenge to someone whose approval we would prefer to retain. This is where a widely shared principle can become a surprisingly lonely responsibility.

Celebrating exceptional people has a complication of its own. We can admire their persistence so warmly that we leave the work with them. Calling someone a hero may be deserved; it can also make their conduct seem beyond anything reasonably expected of the rest of us.

Most of us will never lead a campaign on this scale. We still make decisions about whose education deserves support, whose account we take seriously, and whether an inconvenience is sufficient reason to withdraw something we promised.

A useful response to a story like this would be to revisit one commitment already made. Find out whether it helped. Ask what remains unresolved. If the answer is uncomfortable, resist the urge to replace it with a fresh declaration of concern. The person waiting for that promise to be kept has already heard the declaration.

Privacy choices