Article

Passing On Faith Means Leaving Room for Refusal

November 2, 2026

A family can welcome a child into something it loves long before the child can understand what is being offered. That is part of the tenderness of parenthood, and part of its difficulty. Adults make the decisions; the person who will live with them has yet to find a voice.

The Daily Mail reports that McAleese’s claim that baptising infants breaches their rights has provoked anger. That reported claim alone does not establish a legal conclusion. It does, however, bring a familiar family tension into view: how far does our responsibility to give children a beginning extend into deciding who they must remain?

There is no childhood entirely free of inherited commitments. Even parents who deliberately avoid religion introduce their children to assumptions about what matters, what deserves respect and what can safely be dismissed. Waiting for a child to choose everything independently would itself be a choice, with consequences of its own.

So the fact that an infant cannot consent cannot, by itself, settle every argument about what parents may do. Parenthood requires decisions made on another person’s behalf. The harder issue is whether those decisions can later be questioned without the child being made to feel that the relationship is at stake.

For a parent who understands baptism as a profound good, postponing it may hardly feel neutral. That deserves to be understood rather than brushed aside. Equally, the seriousness of a parent’s belief cannot settle what the child will eventually believe. Love does not give us that reach.

Perhaps the most useful place to take this dispute is beyond the ceremony, into the years when a child begins asking awkward questions. Can a son say he no longer believes without being treated as a family failure? Can a daughter decline a religious practice without having to prove that she still loves her parents?

A family’s answer becomes visible in ordinary exchanges: whether a question is heard, whether disagreement brings withdrawal, whether affection survives an unwelcome decision.

Parents will inevitably pass on a world. They need not apologise for having one to share. But there is a particular responsibility in watching a child grow old enough to examine it. Something offered in love becomes harder to defend when continued acceptance is made the price of belonging.

Privacy choices