Being allowed to make a decision is a rather different thing from being able to make it without fear of the consequences. A woman may have her own plans for work, a relationship or the shape of her family, yet still find that everyone around her considers those plans subject to approval. Freedom becomes exhausting when it has to be negotiated afresh each morning.
That is one reason the choice of a United Nations leader deserves attention beyond diplomatic circles. PassBlue has published a warning that a UAE candidate for UN chief could put women’s rights at risk globally. The headline supplied here does not establish the candidate’s record or demonstrate what they would do in office. It identifies a concern that needs examination, rather than a verdict we should simply inherit.
The useful question is what that examination should demand. A candidate’s nationality cannot settle their fitness for office. Neither should the language of international cooperation allow a candidate’s approach to women’s freedom to escape scrutiny. It is reasonable to ask for evidence of how someone seeking such authority understands the rights of people whose choices may offend powerful interests.
There is a complication. International institutions must work with governments whose values and practices differ, sometimes profoundly. Refusing every conversation with those we oppose would leave very little diplomacy. But cooperation becomes a poor bargain when the people expected to absorb its costs have the least opportunity to refuse them.
For those of us outside the appointment process, the temptation is to treat this as remote machinery. Yet we practise a smaller version of the same judgement whenever we excuse someone’s controlling behaviour because they are effective, well connected or useful to us.
A serious response to PassBlue’s warning would therefore seek the candidate’s record and commitments, and test the warning against them. It would resist both an easy condemnation and an easy reassurance. The women whose freedom is being discussed should not disappear while everyone else congratulates themselves on taking a sensible position. Their ability to make decisions about their own lives is the substance against which those positions need to be judged.